Ad image

Trump and Musk’s Cruelty Put Scrooge and Marley to Shame

9 Min Read

politics



/
December 25, 2024

The president-elect and his unelected billionaire friends have gone completely Dickensian in their attempt to make greed great again.

In the 1938 MGM film, Scrooge, played by Reginald Owen, speaks with his late business partner Marley, played by Leo G. Carroll. christmas carol.

Charles Dickens introduced us to Ebenezer Scrooge, a “wringing, twisting, grasping, scraping, grasping, greedy, old sinner” in one of the most famous morality tales of the 19th century. Today, Scrooge’s name has become synonymous with the kind of revenge and destructive greed practiced by our wealthy class.

no serious readers christmas carol One might suspect that if Dickens, who wrote many of the great literary paeans to the social conscience, were still up to the task, he would be condemning old sinners in the incoming Trump administration. He will take particular issue with the president-elect and his meddler Elon Musk, who has formed a modern-day variation on the Scrooge-Jacob Marley partnership. The afterlife – they were partners in greed.

Trump was narrowly empowered by voters in November, but Musk is not in an elected position. But even if he enjoys relative legitimacy as a ministerial post, that does not justify his slash-and-burn shenanigans in the Ministry of Government Efficiency. Or Trump’s respect for Musk’s shadow government. Neither of these pessimists has a national mandate that they now claim violates the interests of the poor, vulnerable, sick, and elderly.

But as Christmas approached this year, Trump and Musk joined forces to pass a budget resolution. Among its many noble initiatives, the budget bill includes: fight childhood cancerthe two argued that the resolution contained “.unnecessary expense” This intervention by Scrooge, even more so than Scrooge, is due to the increasing influence of unelected billionaires, who are now “mask president” and “Vice President Trump.”

Mr. Musk and Mr. Trump’s attempt to waive the Gabriela Miller Kids First Research Act 2.0 was quickly overturned by a bipartisan coalition in the Senate. But the continuing fiasco of resolutions wasn’t the only Dickensian measure promulgated by Musk and his government efficiency ministry buddy Vivek Ramaswamy. These privileged charlatans, with encouragement from a growing number of Republicans in Congress, are now openly considering the possibility of entitlement cuts that could tear the social safety net to shreds. Many fear it will pave the way for the historic right of the Republican Party. goal of Privatization of Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid.

The headline tells how proponents of the “Make America Great Again” promise defined “again” as sometime in the winter of 1843. rolling stone headline announces“Elon Musk wants to pay for his tax cuts with Social Security and Medicare.”

It’s a thoroughly Dickensian equation, the kind the author had anticipated in the novel’s opening stave. Christmas carol.

Scrooge remembers when he was approached by gentlemen who appealed to him for his “generosity” in “making a small provision for the poor and needy who are now suffering so much.” mosquito?

Scrooge is informed by this sociable do-gooder that “some of us are endeavoring to raise money to buy meat and drink and means of warmth for the poor.” Ta. We choose this time of year because, more than any other time of year, scarcity is acutely felt and abundance is rejoiced. Why should I degrade you? ”

“Nothing!” replied Scrooge. He explained: “I have no intention of pleasing myself at Christmas, nor can I afford to please those who are free.” When informed that he might relieve the burden of the poor, he replied, “It is my business.” No,” he retorted.

So Dickens began christmas carola book called. echoed the radical tenor of the time. When the world began to recognize the truth that poverty and desolation need not be accepted by civil society, by civilized people. Dickens had Scrooge speak the language of corrupt merchants and politicians who opposed the revolutionary movements that were sweeping through Europe at the time the author was writing his ghost stories.

Dickens imagined that cheerful stimulation from the ghosts of Christmases past, present, and future would transform Scrooge. After spending a restless Christmas Eve, receiving reproofs from the deceased and repentant Marley, the businessman hurries out into the streets of London and meets one of the gentlemen. Scrooge announces his intention to donate generously to the current collection, offering, “I assure you that there is a great deal of unpaid money in it.”

The poor suddenly became misers. In other words, Scrooge became “as good a friend, as good a master, and as good a man as any good old city, or any good old city, town, or borough of the good old world.”

Scrooge has changed. But there is still no sign that today’s Scrooge is “shining with the goodness” that made Dickens’ old sinner a better man. In fact, there is every evidence to suggest that Trump and Musk’s atrocities could put Ebenezer Scrooge and Jacob Marley to shame. I just hope that the day will come when we can all enjoy Christmas in good spirits and the ghost of conscience will leave us.


A hostile incoming administration, a massive infrastructure of courts and judges waiting to turn “free speech” into a nostalgic memory, and an old-fashioned press rapidly abdicating its responsibility to provide accurate, fact-based reporting. Independent media is required by institutions to do the job. itself.

in nationwe are bracing ourselves for an uphill battle to defend truth, transparency, and intellectual freedom, but we cannot do it alone.

All presents this month nation By December 31st, the amount you receive will be doubled, up to $75,000. Playing a full game would put $150,000 in the bank in 2025 to fund political commentary and analysis, in-depth reporting, sharp media criticism, and the team that makes it all possible. Masu.

While other news organizations have silenced dissenting voices or softened their approaches; nation remains dedicated to speaking truth to power, engaging patriotic dissent, and empowering readers to fight for justice and equality. As an independent publication, we are not influenced by stakeholders, corporate investors or governments. Our allegiances are to facts and transparency, to honoring our abolitionist roots, to the principles of justice and equality, and to you, our readers.

In the coming weeks and months, the work of free and independent journalists will be more important than ever. People will need accurate reporting, critical analysis, and deep understanding of the issues they care about, from climate change and immigration to reproductive justice and political authoritarianism.

By standing together nation nowyou’re invested not only in independent journalism based on truth, but also in the possibilities that truth creates.

Activated public potential. of a more just society. Meaningful change and a more fundamental, liberated tomorrow.

By acting united,

Dear Editors, nation

John Nichols



John Nichols is a U.S. national affairs correspondent. nation. He has written, co-authored, or edited more than a dozen books on topics ranging from the history of American socialism and the Democratic Party to analyzes of the American and global media systems. His latest work, co-written with Sen. Bernie Sanders, is new york times bestseller It’s okay to be angry at capitalism.

Share This Article
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Exit mobile version