Ad image

Letters: Internal Dissent | The Nation

14 Min Read

letter



/
November 5, 2024

Reader reactions to Intern’s article nationSupports Kamala Harris as presidential candidate.

edit

I write this in response to “Kamala Harris doesn’t deserve it.” nation‘Support’ [TheNation.com, October 25] by nationinterns. I’m probably about the same age as them, but I vehemently disagree. The root of our conflict seems to be: They see voting as an expression of personal ethics, without reservation. it’s not.

Someone will be elected, and someone with a conscience should choose. On January 20th, either Kamala Harris or Donald Trump will stand beneath the Capitol dome. And these people, progressives (!), can’t seem to tell the difference. Or they just don’t care. They just paid lip service to saying, “We know that a second term in office for Mr. Trump will be a disaster, but we believe we cannot vote out of this carnage.” That’s de facto support for Trump. They say we think he’s going to be a terrible person, but we’re not going to vote against him.

It’s these Trump supporters that really excite me. I’m the type of person who knows it’s going to get worse. It’s worse for women, it’s worse for people of color, it’s worse for LGBTQ people, it’s worse for protesters. Millions of people will be harmed by the Trump administration. friends and neighbors.

I know the interns believe Harris is at fault. They have a deep, profound sadness over the war in Gaza. So do I. But the least of us, living right next to you, are counting on you. Women and children in Gaza need protection. But so do American women and children.

Mark KRiesen
Oberyn, oh

The author is a student at Oberlin College.

As a Palestinian American and nation I’ve been a reader since my twenties, and I’ve never been more proud of this publication. The moving editorial just published by an intern is the best thing I’ve read on this subject.

I am disgusted that my own tax dollars are being used by Kamala Harris and Joe Biden to bomb Palestinian babies and kill their mothers. Sponsoring terrorism, genocide, and ethnic cleansing by the State of Israel is appropriate for a war criminal, but not for a U.S. presidential candidate.

Ms. Harris’ reckless, stubborn, and irresponsible decision to turn her back on her base and millions of “uncommitted” voters, all of whom could be her supporters, is outrageous. It’s short-sighted. She proved that her moral and political judgment and leadership were all deeply flawed and a disgrace in the eyes of history.

If Harris loses, there will be no one but himself to blame.

Tah J.W.right
Oakland, California

The author is a trade union representative, political activist, and commentator.

The interns’ position is entirely understandable, as it is based on their complete empathy for the thousands of victims of Israel’s unjust and immoral aggression in a gross overreaction to the Hamas attack on October 7 last year. However, it still shows a fatal naivety. The brutal attacks by Hamas that provoked Israel’s response are not even mentioned, let alone factored into the moral calculus. It is clear that the interns do not know the meaning of the word “genocide” and tend to exaggerate it. War crimes are far more accurate, and Israel has been rightly accused of them by the World Court, with many more to come. I strongly believe that Israel, like Hamas, should face the full consequences of all the war crimes it has committed.

By refusing to endorse Harris, the interns are playing directly into Donald Trump’s hands. By blaming President Biden and Vice President Harris solely for all the death and destruction in Gaza and the surrounding area, they completely exclude Trump and ignore his future role if he becomes president. It would be giving Netanyahu the “green light” to “finish the job,” as Trump himself put it in plain English. What do you think that means? Real genocide, perhaps?

I am fully in favor of halting any further arms sales of any kind to Israel and, if necessary, moving U.S. financial aid to Gaza for humanitarian purposes. For the past several years, in my role as a member of our denomination’s investment committee, I, and we, have had investment brokers invest approximately $10 million in our investment funds into any denomination. We have voted and approved policies that prohibit it. Israeli companies that serve the military or facilitate illegal settlements in the West Bank.

The intern clearly knows nothing about diplomacy. Their position clearly shows their natural ignorance of inexperience.

Thomas J. Pauteur
Minnetonka, Minnesota

The author is a psychologist and a pastor.

I wrote this to express my gratitude to nation Interns appreciated Kamala Harris’ bold stand and provocative appeal to deny her genocidal record. I share their sentiments and vote for Jill Stein.

Denthusiastic GUralie
shaker heights, oh

The author is a professor at Case Western Reserve University.

However nationinterns deny their naivety, saying that politics in America is zero-sum. By not supporting one candidate, you are helping the other. So Americans, certainly people who care about progress, have to look at politics through the lens of better versus worse, and that political progress depends on the efforts of stakeholders and, yes, on stakeholders. We must hold fast to the belief that we will gain slowly through votes.

Repeal might have taken decades longer if early progressives had withheld support from Abraham Lincoln because of his views on Native Americans. If early progressives had withheld their vote for President Franklin Delano Roosevelt over incarceration, America’s most important social welfare expansion would never have happened. Nearly 50 million Americans have access to health care because progressives did not withhold support from Barack Obama, who is reluctant to support same-sex marriage. These people had serious moral flaws and made decisions that caused real harm, and history has rightly condemned their failures. But progress, even for the most progressive among us, depended on choosing better over worse.

Latest issue

The election before us is no exception, but what is at stake is precisely our democracy itself, which has already made progress and whose ability to make progress is still needed. Masu. It’s also not clear how helping Donald Trump, who used “Palestinian” as an insult, will help ease the suffering in suffering Gaza.

Politics is once again asking stakeholders to choose progress over perfection, recognizing that withholding support from better candidates only empowers worse candidates. . Progressives of the past eschewed the furious instinct to demand ideological purity at the expense of achievable progress. If today’s progressives cannot do the same, we will lose everything we have fought for.

IThailand GRoffman
Durham, North Carolina

The author is a student at Duke University School of Law.

I also agree with these young journalists. But now that I’m older, I’m on the side of making or trying to make the most practical decisions.

If Ms. Harris is elected, we can organize and cause her great pain. I’m sorry to have to say this, but there are too many hard-nosed Democrats who don’t think this through. In my 50-odd years of experience in politics, I’ve learned that many Democrats don’t learn and can often only be taught the hard way.

If Trump is elected, we can do business with him. And by the time goodbyes are said and we all leave the room, he’ll break the deal and laugh at how awful we are.

We may be in a better position if Mr. Stein is elected. But realistically, that won’t happen.

If you live in battleground states like Wisconsin, Nevada, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Michigan, Arizona, and Georgia and haven’t voted yet, give democracy a chance by voting for Harris.

If you live in a deep red or dark blue state, vote for Stein and help the Green Party expand its power.

Having visited thousands of times as a candidate, I know that nearly every American hears the words “Oh, that’s why you’re a Republican” or “Oh, that’s why you’re a Democrat” when making a decision. I came to the conclusion that I wanted to use it. They are too busy and don’t know much about politics. Therefore, they conclude that Dr. Stein and other Greens cannot yet participate in our political system. Therefore, they act the same way that mom and dad used to go to parties.

We in America are in turmoil. Regardless of what happens on November 5th, Trump may attempt a second coup. We must save our democracy (despite its current state), and that can only happen with a Harris victory. And through national organizing, we will put pressure and pain on the winners to force change in the rotten political system that brought us to this cliff.

BUzu Davis
Tucson, Arizona

The author is a member of Veterans for Peace in Tucson.

Can I rely on you?

In the upcoming election, the fate of our democracy and fundamental civil rights depends on your vote. Conservative architects of Project 2025 plan to institutionalize Donald Trump’s authoritarian vision at every level of government if he wins.

We have already seen events that fill us with both fear and cautious optimism. nation has been a bulwark against misinformation and advocates for bold, principled viewpoints. Our passionate writers interviewed Kamala Harris and Bernie Sanders, unpacked J.D. Vance’s shallow right-wing populist appeal, and discussed the path to Democratic victory in November.

Stories like this, and the ones you just read, are critical at this critical juncture in our nation’s history. Now, more than ever, we need clear-eyed, deep-reporting independent journalism to make sense of the headlines and separate fact from fiction. Donate today and join our 160-year tradition of speaking truth to power and elevating the voices of grassroots advocates.

We need your support to continue publishing the insightful journalism you rely on throughout 2024 and during what will likely be the defining election of our lifetimes.

thank you,
editor of nation

our readers

Our readers often submit letters to the editor worthy of publication in print or online.

See more nation

In an election where polls show close races between Harris and Trump in battleground states, even a small number could be enough to sway the final outcome.

bob dreyfuss

The “October surprise” occurred in November, when polls suggested there may be one more battleground state than anyone expected.

John Nichols

As Election Day nears, Trump supporters increasingly embrace Dear Leader’s core article of faith: “It’s all about me.”

Chris Lehman

I cannot support the Democratic Party’s position on Gaza, but I recognize that it would be much worse under Trump. That’s why I’m voting for Harris on working family policies…

Cynthia Nixon


Share This Article
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Exit mobile version